Full Episode Transcript
Steven Weinstock (00:00)
What if you could read a real estate market the way you read a clock? Where we are in the cycle, what do you do when the clock hits twelve, three, six, nine? My guest today runs a private equity firm out of Vancouver that buys apartment communities across the US. In his bio, he's been involved in closing more than 200 million dollars in multifamily. and build to rent. And he calls his view of the cycle the multifamily clock. August Biniaz, co-founder, chief investment officer of CPI Capital, is here to walk us through it. Before we jump in, I want to say thank you to everyone watching, every subscriber, everyone who sends me feedback, good or bad. You are the reason this show keeps growing. And it matters more than you know. If you're enjoying the show, hit subscribe right now so you do not miss the next one. And if you want more of this, I wrote a book called The Wealth Clock. The Kindle version is ninety-nine cents. That's the minimum Amazon allows. If you buy it, reach out to me and I will send you free of charge a paperback copy. August is the co-founder and chief investment officer of CPI Capital, where he leads investment strategy, acquisitions, and asset management. He has more than 15 years in real estate. He hosts a podcast of his own. And he is one of the few people I know who can explain how private equity gets started from nothing and how it raises capital from high net worth investors. I wanted him on. Because he does not just talk about cycles, he builds around them. And welcome to the show, August Biniaz. Great to have you.
August Biniaz (02:42)
Steven, thank you for having me. I know that it took a while for us to organize this show, but I really appreciate your patience and that speaks very highly of your your personality and your tenacity and your patience. So that's for anyone listening to you looking to possibly do business with you. They should know that, yeah, for even for recording the show that you're very patient and really appreciate that.
Steven Weinstock (03:04)
Okay, some would say I'm aggressive, you're saying I'm patient. I take them both as a compliment. Thank you, August. first of all, off camera you were helping me with some tech support on my microphone. So if you notice any difference between this episode and the few released before this, please let me know. And I could send August a thank you, letting him know that what he told me is actually the case. August, give me the short version version. Give me the short version. How does someone in Vancouver end up running a private equity firm that is buying multifamily apartments across the US?
August Biniaz (03:46)
Yeah, great question. I think really spawns from a need that exists. Really, I I I hate to say chasing yield, but essentially that's what it is. the yields that are available in US commercial real estate are are surpasses any other yields across the world when it comes to real estate. particularly in in develop in the developed world when you're looking at what are those yields available. I I I would really look at US commercial real estate if you want to look at multifamily, for example, if you looked at it as a commodity, right? So commodities have a certain price around the world. So you c there there is not really a major arbitrage for commodities around the world. Whereas multifamily is similar to that as well, particularly US multifamily. there there is a i if you look at it as a commodity, the yield it produces is higher than buying multifamily in Canada, buying multifamily in UK, buying multifamily in Australia, in Germany. So there's a lot of flow of capital that comes from developed countries into the US because of the yield that US multifamily provides. The other part of it is because such a large demographic within the US uses these these types of communities. more than a hundred million Americans rent and close to fifty million Americans live in some form of an apart apartment community. Now if this is if it's in the Sunbelt, there are more garden style. If it's in more urban areas like the Northeast or California, there are more low rise or high-rise apartment communities. But you have close to 50 million Americans that live there. And r the rent to value ratios that exist in the US are higher than anywhere else in the in the world as much as I've researched. And that's really the impetus for a group like CPI, building his whole platform around the ability to allow Canadian investors to have exposure to US multifamily. We also are involved in build to rent, which is now his own asset class under the commercial real estate umbrella. but yeah, that was really the the start of it is is trying to get bring these deals available for Canadians. Now we obviously partner with US investors as well, but that was really the spawn of it.
Steven Weinstock (05:49)
So I'm gonna go off script here and I just wanna push back a little or really get your opinion. Why why do you think and I'll guess and then you could tell me, you know, your opinion or you know, if I'm wrong, just tell me I'm wrong. But why do you think that the US when it comes to investing in multifamily and maybe some other real estate is such a good opportunity for investors from the rest of the world. Does it have to do with regulation or property rights? Does it have to do with the lending environment, the banking, the loans, that type of environment? does it have to do with just the stability of the US versus other countries? I'm just trying to get your opinion on why that is.
August Biniaz (06:42)
I would say a bit of all of those. So number one, obviously the availability of the the debt that exists in the US. You have agency lenders, Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae, you have insurance companies, you have funds, a lot of providers of debt that's available in the US. that if I make an example to Canada, we don't have as many availabilities in Canada that that the US does. So that's number one. Number two is the wealth that exists in the US. It's highest GDP in the world, wealthiest country in the world. but wealth is not the only reason for this because if you look at northern European countries, some of them are very wealthy on a per capita basis as well, but you don't have the type of yield that exists in the US. So but that is a part of it, the wealth that exists in the US. I think the culture, the investing culture is another part of it. Is if i if you look at the investment world as supply and demand and if the demand is not there for low yields, the market has to fix that for For the consumer, for the investor. So that's another aspect of it. But I think overall it's all of those factors. It's it's also the the volume of people that ex that live in these communities as well. And you gotta keep in mind American vo workforce, the income that they make between, you know, let's say the workforce makes between and I'm just pulling these numbers out of thin air, but between fifty and a hundred thousand dollars a year. The workforce makes that type of income and they spend one third of that on shelter. That is a significant amount of money going into rental and w we know that workforce is the number one consumer of of apartments and r rental stock. So a combination of all of those those factors. But it but that's another great question you had, I belie I I would say.
Steven Weinstock (08:21)
Let us talk about your multifamily clock. In one in one sentence, what is the multifamily clock and what does each hour on it mean?
August Biniaz (08:35)
Multifamily clock is just a process to look at real estate cycles, particularly multifamily cyc cycles, in a shape of a clock. So and and when you look at a clock, a clock doesn't really have any major significance. But in the case of a multifamily clock or a real estate clock or some type of financial cycle clock, the twelve o'clock is top of the market, is absolute mania. you have people throwing money at deals, you have people putting on non-refundable deposits day one. The market is through going through absolute mania. And six o'clock is the bottom of the market where people are walking away from deposits. You have a lot of distress in the space. you have operational distress. You have debt distress. You have a lot of different headwinds in the market. And then you have your your three o'clock and nine o'clock are kind of different phases of the mar the market cycle. But looking at it from a clock kind of view. or analogy allows you to look at the market cycles a bit better. Even though market cycles go in kind of ebbs and flows, but when you look at it as a clock it's kind of it's more paddle paddleable, it's more easier to consume.
Steven Weinstock (09:38)
Just to where are we on that clock right now? What do you think?
August Biniaz (09:44)
Yeah, I would say that if you asked me the same question a few months ago, maybe three months ago, I would say we're either very close to six o'clock or right at six o'clock. But today I would move the clock back a bit and I would say we're probably close to five or five thirty. I would say we have not hit the bottom of the market yet in in multifamily in particular. and the reason behind that is two of my top reasons. Number one, we have a lot of debt maturing. over the next I would say six months, we have close to a trillion dollars, close to there is eight hundred and sixty billion dollars in commercial loans maturing. Approximately one third of that is multifamily. So there's a lot of debt maturing and a lot of that debt that's maturing, it was locked in when rates were very low, historical low low rates. And we know that commercial loans, their terms are much lower than residential loans. They're usually three years, five years or so. So a lot of those loans are maturing when the owners have to go back and and get new debt, the debt is not at much higher interest rate relative where it was when they locked it in. The the real estate market is in a much different stage than it was when they locked it in. So valuations have dropped. rents have dropped nationwide, occupancy have dropped because a lot of oversupply that came on. Again, cheap debt was a reason a lot of oversupply was built. so you have this perfect storm when it comes to multifamily or commercial real estate in general that it's it's it's all taking place around this time. You also have that compounded by the Iran war that's taking place in the Middle East that's cause inflationary. You have this administration's policies when it comes to immigration, that is also inflationary, when it comes to ICE agents and what have you, which are both tenants of of a lot of apartment communities that that we own and operate, but also are a lot of service providers for for development and renovation projects. So those again, it it it is a perfect storm when it comes to the market cycle and where we are at today. So I would savor We're probably between five and five thirty, five fifteen today on the multifamily clock.
Steven Weinstock (12:03)
Well, you're gonna have a lot of people who need to refinance. And I guess as you get closer to the six o'clock, these people who need to refinance, they're gonna come to the bank and realize that they're gonna have to add capital just to refinance. You're gonna have people who have a a ten million dollar property, for example. they currently have a a seven million dollar loan on it, maybe it was interest only all this time, maybe a small principal c payment component towards the end. And they're gonna come today or, you know, in thirty minutes, on your clock. And they're gonna need to refinance just to get out of the loan. And the valuation on the property might only be It might still be ten million. It might not be higher. It might be very possibly lower. For no fault really on their own of their own. You know, rents, you know, might be stable and collections may be okay. And just based on the interest rates, you're gonna have a loan or a lender that's only gonna lend, you know, six million or six and a half million instead of the seven million that they had. What are these owners, what are these GPs, what are they gonna do? some of them will be forced to sell. they're gonna try to sell it for they'll probably try to list it for at least what they bought it. And, you know, they may have to cut the price. Is that is that what you mean by the six o'clock where just bun a bunch of these owners and landlords are in that situation?
August Biniaz (13:33)
Six o'clock is just the phase of the market. Now, what happens when it comes to the distress that exists, operational or debt distress that exists in the space, that's a factor of us being at six o'clock. but six o'clock just tells us where we're at. But yes, absolutely. Those items that you said are spot on. So if you bought a property at for ten million dollars three years ago or four years ago or five years ago, and your loan has now matured, when you come in to you to your to your lender when you ha when you're having a you know your discussions about refinancing or you know g getting a new loan, your property is worth much less. This is nationwide, particularly in multifamily, sorry, in in the Sunbelt, multifamily has values have dropped significantly because occupancy has dropped, rents have dropped, and expenses have increased post COVID and so on. Obviously we can see with prices with oil and gas and and diesel and so on. So transportation costs have increased. So your expenses are more, your your obviously debt is much more, your your occupancy is less. So they're they're they're yeah, in a lot of cases they're either being forced to bring in more capital to the deal or they're being forced to sell the property. And is is is at times the property is really worth less than the note price. we were working on a property in Dallas that eventually the deal unfortunately collapsed, but we were purchasing the deal below the note price. So this is ha this happening every day. Just to give you some high level numbers, I was discussing this and this is public record, people can actually Google this, but I was looking at Freddie Mac's loans on their their books. They have five hundred and sixty loans in special servicing. And in in in multifamily, when you have a loan that's below one DSCR, meaning that the NOI is not able to cover the the debt payment, you go into special servicing. So actually less than one point two five you go into special servicing, but less than one you're you're on a on on this list. So there's five hundred and sixty properties that are in special servicing with with Freddie Mac alone. And another number that I got is that over a thousand apartment communities in Dallas Fort Worth currently are selling sitting below one D S C R. A thousand apartment communities. So this is again, these are just numbers that I'm throwing at you, but that kind of gives you an idea of where we are at within the cycle. But also news as well. A lot of times, you know, we talked about private equity at the beginning of the show. Blackstone is the largest private equity firm in the world. They have one point $3 trillion assets under management. And their assets under management are not the way calculated the way BlackRock's assets under management says, because BlackRock is a money manager. So the money that they manage is on their books as well. And counting that over $10 trillion that they have. In the case of Blackstone, this is actually properties or assets or companies that they own, $1.3 trillion. And Blackstone is having trouble with one of their multifamily funds currently. and They're in a bad situation, so they're defaulting on their loan. So to give you an idea, their perspective there, this is not in any way advocating for syndicators who were too aggressive and they were prodigal with their investors' capital. This is saying that this is a situation where everybody's getting caught. And and I want to make a point about Blackstone. Blackstone, in one of their recent hiring rounds, they had over 90,000 people who applied and they hired less than a quarter percent of those applicants. So it just talks talk tells you about the type of caliber of analyst, caliber of employees, of executives, of directors that they bring on, and they still got it wrong. Again, this is not advocating for people who were too aggressive and messed up big time, but it just tells you where we are at in the in the current market.
Steven Weinstock (17:31)
Walk me through how you actually launch a real estate private equity firm from the ground up. What did you need to have in place before you ever asked anybody for money?
August Biniaz (17:45)
So you definitely have to have a few screw loose in your head to want to go and start a real estate private equity firm from the ground up. no, I I really mean that. I mean the the the best path to success in the private equity space when you look at read the books of Steve Schwarzman and and others is someone who's left a private equity firm and branched off. we talked about BlackRock, for example. Black Rock is an offshoot from Blackstone. You know, the team was working for Blackstone when they went and started BlackRock. So Those offshoots are usually the path of least resistance and the most common path of you seeing private equity firms being built because they're within that firm, they've learned the business, now they go and start it out. with us at CPI, it it was it really started out with an idea of allowing Canadian investors to have exposure to US multifamily and wanting to be an institution from day one, but wanting to be a real estate private equity firm from from day one and building the firm around that the idea. but it's definitely not a not an easy process. Obviously, there's a compliance element of it because you're out there raising capital from members of the public. There's a marketing component because people need to know who you are and there needs to be a brand around the company and the the executives. There is an operational aspect where on the acquisition front you have to have your your analysts and your team there, your relationship with brokers, relationship with lenders, and then on the asset management side, you need to have your in-house asset manager who are gonna oversee the the property and execution of the business plan. So a lot of moving parts there. it it's it's definitely not a business for the the faint heart, hearted someone who's faint hearted, but it's it it is the most dynamic business. It has the I always since I was young, I always understood this concept. And I think I was I really have had it in my blood. This concept of the upside. I always was excited about businesses that provide the the the highest potential of upside. for example, if you are you know in a in a pr i i if you're in a profession, if you work for a corporation or you work for a company, if you're an electrician, for example, not to pick on you know the tradesman here or anything, but there there's a ceiling that you eventually head. If you're a real estate agent, that's a very common one. There's a ceiling that you head when it comes to being a real estate agent. You know, some of the top real estate agents make a million dollars a a year. I always enjoyed businesses that had the highest potential for upside. And in the private equity world, it has the highest ceiling that exists, really, for the upside that exists, the highest growth potential that exists. you have the same thing in l in a lot of other creative businesses out there. but that's what excites me. So private equity allows for that. As long as you're good at finding a business and and and when I say business, real estate a lot of times is a business in itself as well. But if you're good at sourcing deals, be it real estate or otherwise, you're good at executing the business plan and able to raise the capital needed, this there is really there's no limit. the the the sky is almost nonexistent.
Steven Weinstock (20:52)
How'd you get into real estate? What'd you do what was your first job?
August Biniaz (20:57)
My first job, my first job was McDonald's. So I was flipping burgers at McDonald's in my first job. but real estate was well w which McDonald's teaches you a lot of systems as well. So it's an important system business that it is. So a lot of those systems can can be used for the rest of your life really, what you learn at at McDonald's. But real estate was something that was in with my family, my maternal grandfather was a real estate broker. my mom was a real estate investor, so I understood real state. if it was a language I spoke it. I grew up in Iran and Iran has gone through you know obviously since the mullahs have took over Iran and you know turned it back into this draconian you know regime that's running Iran and turn it back to this archaic country, unfortunately what has happened to the great Iranian people. But for the last fifty years, Iran has gone through hyperinflation. And one of the best ways to battle inflation is to buy r tangible and real assets, gold, silver, real estate, and a lot of Iranians do that. There isn't a big equities market in Iran, stock market, not that I knew of when I was living there, or my family knew of. But real estate was a very common thing in Iran that people would invest in real estate. So I understood real estate from a young age and this concept of trying to insulate yourself from inflation. So when I was in my early twenties it was just a natural thing to get involved in real estate, got my license in my early twenties and started the space from there.
Steven Weinstock (22:31)
you have one of those biggest one of the biggest mall operators in America and Canada. Mall of America, here on the East Coast we have American Dream Mall. I think in Edmonton, you have I forgot what it's called, but it's also one of the large
August Biniaz (22:44)
West Ed West Ed West Edmonton Mall, yeah. The Ghermezians, yes.
Steven Weinstock (22:47)
And from what I understand that's a bunch of Iranian brothers. maybe it started with a a parent or so. And I believe they raised capital from a bunch of family members still in Iran who needed to place their funds in a in a good place. I guess they were dealing with what you said hyperinflation, obviously instability. obvious nineteen seventy nine I think was the tipping point. so yeah, I mean, being coming from that background, I can only imagine how tough it's been, but you know, how driven you are. You know, you have a lot of people born here, here in the US or even in Canada, and never know what it's like to you know, they they know it's like to struggle, but Coming from your background, hearing about it, living through it through ancestors and and relatives and grandparents, definitely drives you to to invest and put the money in what you said, tangible assets, things that are inflation proof, I guess. you know, people who own assets, people who own real estate. They love inflation. yes, it might it might cost them some money when they're buying milk, and and other items and and not to knock it. But if they could have the bulk of their money in assets, like even you know, stock in certain stocks, certain buildings, if they have real estate debt, inflation comes and they win because that million dollar loan that they had yesterday and now that ten percent inflation hit tomorrow That million dollar loan is effectively a nine hundred thousand dollar loan. And you know, they win. They win. Yeah, they're paying extra for milk, but you know, if they if they have you know, fifty million dollars in loans, you know, they really they really win with this. So you know, interesting take on what you said about Iran and the hyperinflation. I I felt I just wanted to go into a tangent over there. Hope you don't mind.
August Biniaz (24:48)
For sure, for sure. me if I misquoted the family's name. Their family's name is Ghermezian. And they left Iran pre seventy nine revolution. And and yeah, they're still based in I believe they're based their main offices are in Edmonton, I believe, where West Edmonton Mall is, either Edmonton or Calgary, but they're definitely based out of Alberta and they really grew from there. So yeah.
Steven Weinstock (25:10)
Yeah, I know them as the Ghermezian, but that's my New York American way of pronouncing it. I like the way you add your extra twang or Iranian twang to it. I'm not gonna try to repeat the way you said it, but yeah, Ghermezian or however you said it is correct. see you're in real estate. did you ever invest in Canada? Did you ever try investing locally?
August Biniaz (25:37)
I did. I was a home builder. I was home builder for a decade in Canada. So I did make a lot of investments, not only in the projects I built in other investments as well. I still have some investments in Canada, but when you again look at the US and the opportunities that exist here and opportunities for growth, the debt environment that exists here in the US, the the consumer, the investor class, it just it's makes bl more sense to be here. And in and the Canadian side as well, if you look at the Canadian elite, a lot of them do live in the US, they invest in the US. same thing with a lot of Canadian institutions. The Canadian Pension Fund, which is the largest pension fund in Canada, has partnered with Greystar, which is the largest owner operator of apartments in the US to build and operate apartments. So that flow of capital has been taking place. it's not August Biniaz and CPI Capital who figured this out, but that's been happening on both institutional and retail level for decades the flow of capital from Canada into the US.
Steven Weinstock (26:34)
When you're purchasing these properties, how involved are you with the actual management and the day to day? Are you guys the GP? Are you partnering with local GPs? How do you how when you how are you structuring these and how how are you how are you operating these properties?
August Biniaz (26:55)
Yeah, on the operational side, if we do acquire multifamily, we're hiring a third party property manager. Our in house asset management team oversees the property manager and making sure they're hitting all the the you know the the numbers they need to hit and and so on. On the development front, we also do development deals when it comes to build to rent in Texas. We're building projects in San Antonio and DFW, built to rent communities. And on those projects we have partnered with a local developer. out of out of Texas and we partner with them on a joint venture basis. coming back to multifamily, it really depends on the deal, right? And where the deal came from, where was the source, who are the partners, how large is the deal. the great thing about the world that we're in, the private equity world, these deals can be structured any way we we we wish. There there's a lot of there is a lot of flexibility in how you structure deals. So yes, the deals could be structured in a joint venture setting where we're sponsors and our partners are sponsors. It could be a co-GP where we are the sponsor and we have other partners who join us on deals. it really depends on the deal, depends on the market. But yeah, on the operational side, be it on the multifamily front or be it on the development front, we have our in house asset management steam team that oversees the operations, both on the construction development front and on the acquisition value add front.
Steven Weinstock (28:21)
Are there any states here in the US that is almost an instant no when it comes across your desk as far as investing in?
August Biniaz (28:31)
Well, we're very focused on Texas and Florida. So obviously it's it's well known that there is a lot of states out there that are not friendly to investing. You have your California and and New York, so that's the dead giveaway right there. But with us we're hyper focused on Texas and Florida. each state individually has a larger economy than the whole country of Canada. They have a larger GDP than Canada does. Their population is close to half or more than half of Canada's population. a a lot of economic drivers, Fortune five hundred companies that are headquartered there, the population growth that exists in both Texas and Florida. I mean you just can't can't compete with these with these two states. So that's that's our focus within those states. Now where within those states in Texas we're focused on San Antonio and DFW. and in Florida we're hyper focused on Tampa Bay. Tampa Bay kind of checks off the boxes that we like within that market. and and so on. So those are those are our market focuses.
Steven Weinstock (29:30)
Okay, August, what do you do for fun outside of real estate? Are you reading books, you watching Netflix, are you helping at a soup kitchen, helping old ladies cross the street? What do you do for fun?
August Biniaz (29:44)
number one is my I'm a dad. I'm a I'm somewhat of a newer dad. I have two sons. both are under three. I can't believe that. my god. They're still under three. And I have another baby on the way in mid December here, December seventeenth. Our babies do, but they tend to be a couple of days late. so been been having a blast being a dad for the last few years and enjoying my kids growing up and having a lot of fun with them. other than that, I'm an avid skier. So you find me skiing in the mountains of Colorado or west coast of Canada in the wintertime. This year we'll be in in in Colorado for for a month, from mid February to mid March. So looking forward to that. So if you're hearing this and you're gonna be skiing, let me know. Hit me up, hit August Biniaz up. yeah, on the personal side, I I mean if we have a lot of ideas as far as kind of giving back and so on, We just want to head velocity from on CPI before you know, everybody kind of talks about in some cases brags about kind of giving back and and and so on. I just I just want the company to be at at a at a stage before we go and launch a charity and so on. But that that is definitely a part of what we want to do, giving back as well. but but yeah, high level
Steven Weinstock (31:03)
we're gonna end. but I have a one last question. If someone was listening to this podcast and they wanted to start investing passively in apartments this year, what is the first step you would tell them to take?
August Biniaz (31:20)
First step is under g finding out what is their why. Why do you want to invest in apartments? Understanding the asset class, understanding you know w wha what what is it? So make sure you get over that first step because if you just saw something on social media or or YouTube and now you wanna go invest in it. So t spend some time. I know they call it passive, but there is an active part to wanting to invest. So understand the asset class, understand why you're investing, understand the options that exist. you can have exposure to multifamily through public REITs. Obviously the returns are much lower than syndicated investments through an operator like CPI. But maybe the first step is to go and check out a public REIT and make an investment there to understand the mechanics of how this deal works. But be an educ be a be a student of the game, understand it. when you have when you're past that step and you actually are interviewing and you're qualifying different sponsors to partner with. Partner talk talk to a few of them. see how they operate, how how do they communicate, do they have an educational aspect to what they do, educate their investors, understand what market you wanna be in. Just because you want to spend invest in multifamily. You could invest in multifamily in any of the states in the US and fifty states, but what states do you want where do you wanna be? Why do you want to invest? And then you go and find the right operator who's gonna who's gonna be the right team for you to be able to partner with and invest with. And always believe in your gut in your gut feeling. go by your gut feeling always because it's probably right in most cases.
Steven Weinstock (32:50)
August, where can people find you? Where can they find CPI Capital? And where can they find your podcast?
August Biniaz (32:57)
Yeah, cpicapital.com is our website. A lot of great information on there. You have a link to our podcast from the website there. We have our webinar masterclass that you can only access through our website. So cpicapital.com. I'm personally very active on LinkedIn. I'm a LinkedIn top voice. So reach out to me, August Biniaz on LinkedIn, send me a message, tell me you've seen me on the show. I love to connect and chat. and our podcast is Real Estate Investing Demystified right here. And I think we're gonna have Steven on the show at in a soon time here. So catch Steven's episode when he comes on.
Steven Weinstock (33:31)
Okay, August, that was great. I'm gonna put this in the show notes. he you are definitely active on LinkedIn. August Biniaz, B-I-N-I-A-Z. For those of you who need to learn how to spell last names. August, it was great. I appreciate it. Thank you for the tech support. this microphone only exists and working because of August taking his time out before we hit the record and made sure that He sounds good. Well, no, actually, no. Make sure that I sound good so that he could sound good. August, thank you very much. I appreciate it. If you got something out of this episode, hit subscribe, leave a comment, share it with someone who is thinking about getting into real estate. I will see you on the next episode of The Wealth Clock.