Episode 63

    How a Co Op Board Cut $340,000 and Froze Maintenance for 8 Years

    Mark Foley — President, The Folson Group

    43:32

    Mark Foley, co founder and President of The Folson Group, has been a co op board president in New York City for 15 years. He and his wife, both former Wall Street business analysts, reviewed their own building's books like an investor would. Mark says they cut about $340,000, around 10% of the budget at the time, and went 8 years without a maintenance increase while still doing major capital projects and growing the reserve fund.

    Mark joins Steven Weinstock to explain how a co op differs from a condo, how a line by line cost review with benchmarks works, and the questions that uncover the money. He also tells stories about a $125,000 insurance savings one board turned down, kickbacks, and the most common money mistakes boards make, then shares simple fixes a small building owner can make this week.

    Everything in this episode is Mark's own recollection and opinion. The $30,000 kickback story is a resident's account that Mark repeats, not something he witnessed. This episode is for education and entertainment only and is not financial, legal or tax advice.

    Key Takeaways

    • 1Mark and his wife, both former Wall Street business analysts, reviewed their co op's books by asking one question: if this building were a company, would we recommend buying it?
    • 2Over a couple of years they cut about $340,000, which Mark says was 10% of the budget at the time, and went 8 years without a maintenance increase while doing major capital projects and growing the reserve fund
    • 3His firm looks at every line item, even in a budget of 450 line items, compares costs to benchmarks such as insurance per unit, and starts with the items that are way out of whack
    • 4Mark brings a board about 4 ideas a month because that is what a volunteer board with day jobs and families can handle
    • 5A $125,000 insurance savings one board turned down, even though the managing agent was also an owner of the insurance company, and a lawyer friend told Mark that goes beyond a violation of fiduciary duty
    • 6Kickbacks and favors Mark has heard about or seen, including a resident's account of a $30,000 kickback on a roof leak repair and a building whose dry cleaning bills were cut in half after the super left
    • 7The mistake Mark sees most is boards not treating the building like a business, and his restaurant owner example: the owner is there every time, he does not meet his manager 1 hour a month
    • 8Easy savings for a small building: hallway lights on motion sensors, energy efficient bulbs and appliances, and low flow fixtures with a 1.2 gallon toilet maximum when owners renovate
    • 9Income ideas for a building: laundry rooms, storage units, parking spots that are rented or sold, and private rentals of a roof deck

    What This Episode Explains

    • How experienced investors approach risk management and capital protection
    • How real estate syndications and fund structures create investor opportunities
    • How multifamily investments are evaluated, acquired, and managed
    • How tax strategies and depreciation impact real estate investment returns
    • How real estate operators scale their businesses and portfolios
    • Insights from Mark Foley's experience as President, The Folson Group

    This episode features a conversation with Mark Foley on The Wealth Clock with Steven Weinstock.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    How did Mark Foley's co op board cut $340,000?
    Mark and his wife, who both worked as business analysts on Wall Street, got the building's books and asked whether they would recommend buying the building if it were a company. Over a couple of years they cut about $340,000, which Mark says was 10% of the budget at the time, and the building went 8 years without a maintenance increase while still doing major capital projects and growing its reserve fund.
    What is the difference between a co op and a condo?
    Mark says that in a condo you own real property and your unit is your own tax lot, while in a co op you buy shares in a corporation that owns the building and you are assigned a proprietary lease. The monthly charge is called common charges in a condo and maintenance in a co op, and in a co op roughly 50% of it is real estate taxes.
    What was the $125,000 insurance story?
    Mark says one of his partners put together an insurance proposal that could have saved a building $125,000. The board stayed with its managing agent, who was also an owner of the insurance company. Mark says a lawyer friend told him that is actionable and goes beyond a violation of fiduciary duty.
    What can a small building owner do this week to save money?
    Mark suggests energy efficient appliances and bulbs, putting hallway lights on motion sensors so they are not fully lit from midnight to 6 AM, and requiring low flow fixtures, with a 1.2 gallon toilet maximum, when an owner renovates a bathroom. He says that over 4 or 5 years about 25% of units get renovated, which can add up.
    How can a building bring in extra income?
    Mark names laundry rooms, storage units in the basement, parking spots that are rented or sold, and renting the roof deck for private parties. Retail space the building owns can also produce rent. He says renting spots creates a steady stream, while selling gets more money up front but cannot be sold again.
    What is the biggest mistake boards make?
    Mark says it is not treating the building like a business. He says a board cannot just hire a property manager and trust them, because the board is the board of directors, and he compares it to a restaurant owner who is there every time you visit. He also says boards should follow their bylaws and house rules and treat everyone the same.

    Episode Sponsors

    WE Capital Mortgage Fund logo

    WE Capital Mortgage Fund invests in fully vetted, first-lien bridge loans backed by real estate collateral, with a focus on capital protection and consistent income.

    CableNOI logo

    CableNOI helps apartment owners unlock hidden NOI by renegotiating, restructuring, or replacing bulk cable and internet agreements. The result is higher property income with zero tenant disruption.

    Podclyp

    AI turns your podcast into short clips for TikTok, Reels and YouTube Shorts. Free in beta.

    Full Episode Transcript

    Steven Weinstock (00:00) What if the biggest money in your building is sitting in the expense line? Nobody questions. My guest today, Mark Foley, spent 15 years as a co-op board president in New York City, and he's the co-founder of the Folson Group, which helps co-op and condo boards control costs and manage big capital projects. He comes from the world of finance and economics, so he looks at a building the way an investor would. Today he walks us through how that kind of review works, the questions that uncover the money, and why the same review applies to any multifamily owner looking at operating expenses. Before we get started, I want to say thank you to everybody who watches, to everybody who listens, to all the subscribers, everyone who sends me feedback. And I'm talking to everybody, even the negative feedback that I get. So keep it coming. I like it. I enjoy it. I will respond to you. You are the reason this show keeps growing, and it matters to me more than you know. If you're getting value from the show, please hit subscribe. It's free and it helps me, my podcasts, reach out to more people with the algorithm. I also wrote a book called The Wealth Clock. The Kindle version is 99 cents. And that's only because Amazon doesn't allow me to give it out for free. But if you buy it for 99 cents, reach out to me and I will ship you a hard copy for free. Hopefully you enjoy it. Steven Weinstock (02:23) And welcome to the show, Mark Foley. Mark Foley (02:27) Thank you, Steven. Good to be here. Steven Weinstock (02:29) Okay, so you come from the world of finance. How did you end up spending 15 years as a co-op board president? And before you get into that, I live in New York. I'm born and raised in Brooklyn. I know very well what a co-op is. There's a lot of people out there who have no clue what a co-op is. They've heard of condos. There's different legalities, different ownership structures. So let's get into that and how you got into this. Mark Foley (03:00) Sure, excuse me. So the difference between a co-op and a condo. For the layman or somebody who's just living in a building, there's virtually no business. as you mentioned, it is in the ownership. If you are if you have a condominium, you own real property and you have your own tax lot, that unit is your tax lot and you own it outright. In a co-op, you're buying shares into a corporation. The corporation owns the building. You are then assigned a proprietary lease. So the monthly fees you pay in a condo, they're called common charge. Common charges in a co-op, it's called maintenance. Think of that as your rent. In a co-op, it actually is rent because you have a proprietary lease that you're paying into. You don't own real property, you own shares into a corporation. Now when you sell, you're selling your shares to somebody else. They take over that lease and that apartment. So again, the mechanics are slightly different, but day-to-day operations, there's not a whole lot of yeah, th there's nothing that's gonna slap you in the face. when you said I w was fifteen years as a co-op board president. It is fifteen years in counting, I still am. And why would I want to do that? And the answer was out of necessity. I felt that our my wife and I, my wife is my partner. we bought into a co-op twenty something years ago, twenty-two I think. And we really weren't happy with the way the building was being run. the board was it was kind of one of those nightmare boards that you read about, or like an HOA association. just kind of ruling by fiat, acting with impunity, not really following the bylaws or even house rules. If they liked you, you they were nice to you. If they didn't like you, they would go out of their way to not be nice to you. so In my particular case, I won't get into all the details. you don't have time, but I ended up suing the building. And I actually got elected to the board. We put together a ticket, you know, r opposition ticket to the board at the annual annual meeting, annual elections. And I got elected to the board with an open lawsuit against the building. That's how bad it was. So we had expected to find and and one of the things that irked us besides our personal problems were that the monthly charges every year kept going up more and more and more, well beyond the rate of inflation. Back, you know, back in 2004, 2006, inf inflation was you know virtually zero. So we're like, you know, we we're business people. We we don't understand why this is. So we get the books, we're combing through them. Both my wife and I are background as business analysts on Wall Street. We look at the building as a business, and that's how everybody needs to look at their own building, because it is a business. So we said, okay, as an analyst, if we're if this building were a company, would we recommend buying this company? And if not, how would we make it run more efficiently? So over the course of a couple of years, we cut our budget by about $340,000, which at the time was 10% of our budget. So that's that's major money. And we actually went eight years without a maintenance increase while balancing the budget, and including doing major capital projects, repairs, et cetera. And we actually increased our reserve fund. So our building had had a bad reputation. So as you know, I become board president, I I want to get eyeballs on the building and it's you know supply and demand-ish. So I'm bringing in real estate brokers, I'm giving them tours, I'm explaining, we're we're a new building. We're not the building you thought of five years ago that you wouldn't show. There were real estate agents who would not show our building. I said, look, we have a new board, we have a new superintendent, we have a new lawyer, and we have a new manager. We're completely new building. And I give them a tour, explain the finances, and they'd say, Well, you know, ha ha, wow, we know, wish you could be on our board. And My wife was getting that, she was talking of her friends and sh she was networking for our financial firm. And if you're networking and you say, I have a re registered investment advisory, that's like saying, I sell life insurance. Nothing wrong with selling life insurance, but you know how many people when you you y you say that and they go, So she said, Well on the plus side, I helped save my building three hundred and forty thousand dollars. They said, Really, tell me more. So I'm getting this on one side, she's getting that on the other. We just had the idea to hang out a shingle and Try to apply that to other buildings, and here we are. Steven Weinstock (07:32) wow. So f first question, are buildings today that are constructed are they still under the co op model? Is this an older feature that is out of date? And is this strictly New York City with co ops? Mark Foley (07:48) mostly in New York, I believe Chicago has some, Boston, maybe a handful, but it's it's most typical to New York. in the old days, and even when when I bought mine twenty two years ago, whatever, it was probably eighty twenty or even ninety ten co-op to condo. And these days it's probably 70 or even 60, 70, 30, 60, 40. Virtually every new building that's going up is a condo. it's I believe it's just easier for people to live. They have more freedom. You can sublet if you want. You because it again, you own real property in a co-op, you have to get approval. you know, it's a little bit easier purchasing. Generally the down payment is less. the The board is much easier because you're you know you're you're just buying and the co-op a condo has right of first refusal. So if they don't like you for whatever reason, they can match the price and buy it themselves. That's not common because it's a lot of money. With a co-op, you know, you have to meet certain criteria and we've all read the horror stories of people who are, famous people who are turned down because, we don't like that kind of people, or entertainers, or whatever else. yeah, but there's plus and minuses too. So if you live in a condo and you know Puff Daddy moves next door to you, you there's nothing you can do. in a co-op they'd say, Mr. Daddy, we we don't really want any freak off parties going on here. So we're you you might be more comfortable somewhere else. Steven Weinstock (09:22) just a quick note over there. When he says Puff Daddy he is aging himself. I believe he is known as P. Diddy right now. but that's fine. Mark Foley (09:29) you're right. I've been telling that story that long, that's how it is. Steven Weinstock (09:37) why why do we even have co op and and not condo? And why why did it used to be more co-op? Why did it change I I understand why it changed. I condo is just Mark Foley (09:49) Okay. Steven Weinstock (09:50) easier, people feel, you know, they own it. I know when it comes to financing, there's you know, banks and lenders that might not necessarily want to lend on a co-op. obviously you have specific lenders that specialize in co-ops. Why why did co ops ever get invented, as opposed to the condo model? Mark Foley (10:12) Sure, so if you go back, you know, a hundred years or even the turn of the century, late 1800s, most people either lived in a an apartment, generally a tenement, and then there was the you know wealthy, wealthier, not even necessarily the gilded class, but the wealthier they had their own either townhouse or you know mansions on Fifth Avenue, the west side, whatever. And the idea of the people at the time termed it, you know, who would want to live on a shelf? And it was just distasteful. So finally they built some luxury buildings. The Dakota was one of the first named the Dakota because at the time 72nd Street was so far away out in the wild that it might as well be in the Dakotas. eventually, you know, they built luxury buildings. That had such great amenities and were just s so easy to live with, and they were much larger at the time. Many of them have been subdivided down now, but you had staff rooms in there. y you know, you had all the luxuries, plus somebody else was taking care of it, plus you had a doorman, you had a mailroom, driver, all this other stuff. And the plus side that they considered was they wanted to be with people like themselves. So in a co-op, it was a community, you get to choose who your neighbor is going to be. If you don't like them, you don't get in. If you're the wrong class, if you're wrong religion, whatever. Yeah, many buildings were restricted. 740 Park Avenue, which was developed actually by Jackie Bouvier, Jackie, Jackie Kennedy, her father, they typically had one Jewish apart. They didn't discriminate. They had one Jewish apartment. And if somebody else wanted to get in, they had to wait till that person moved or died. So it you know, it was very waspy, old society, so to speak. you know, if you're a black, forget it, you aren't gonna get in. And that was a start. Then, you know, people decided, wait, we don't, you know, times change. People said, hey, we don't, you know, we don't want to live like this. We don't want to have somebody judging me, and I don't want to be with those snobs. Anyway, let's come up with a structure that you know physical and business structure that you know regular people can just buy, you buy a place. And that's how it began. And that's why today it's you know virtually always. As far as financing, there, you know, the banks in New York obviously are aware of it. Occasionally there will be a lender who has an office in Ohio and they say, what what is this? You don't own anything? And then you have to explain. And we we've in my building, we've worked with a lot of banks and mortgage lenders to get pre-approval. They know what it is, so so it's you know, whatever. But in New York, you're generally required to have a higher down payment in a co-op. So in New York the lenders would prefer because there's much less risk for them. Condo can be ten percent, even as little as five percent down. So you're buying a five million dollar condo, it's a pretty big mortgage. Steven Weinstock (13:16) Yeah, wow. you mentioned the Dakota. I know what that is. I'm here in New York. Dakota is that famous building on right off seventy second and I guess Broadway. And it's Mark Foley (13:29) Central Park West. Steven Weinstock (13:30) Centr that's Central Park West, okay. and that's where John Lennon from the Beatles was living and killed, correct? Mark Foley (13:38) Correct, right up front. Steven Weinstock (13:40) Yeah, yeah. I too young to remember the story, but being a New Yorker, I've heard it many times. I think it's sometime in December. I know they had anniversaries or celebrations, etcetera. Mark Foley (13:54) Yeah, no, it was it was December, I forget the date, but I'm old enough. Steven Weinstock (13:57) I think it's it's it's the day the day before or the day after Pearl Harbor, if I'm not mistaken. Mark Foley (14:05) could be. I was gonna say the ninth, but that's maybe it's the eighth or sixth. I I I honestly don't know. Steven Weinstock (14:12) Yeah. Mark Foley (14:12) I but I do remember remember at the time there was no social media, there was no 24-hour news like we had. So I was in college, we were watching Monday night football, and I think a lot of the country learned about his his murder from Howard Cosell. Steven Weinstock (14:29) Wow. Wow. okay Mark Foley (14:32) And for those who are too young, Howard Cosell used to be a very important broadcaster. Steven Weinstock (14:36) Yes, yes, yes. What questions when you're analysing the books of a of a co-op, what w how do they find you? Why why are they looking for you? And then what steps do you take once you actually get the books and you know, start doing due diligence? Mark Foley (14:56) Sure. So a lot of boards hire us because maybe they were in a situation that I was that they that you know they felt compelled to do it, but they don't know what and and how to do it. You know, they might be experts in law, they might be doctors, they might work for a finance company, but they're maybe not in the analysis side of things. So, okay, what do we do? How do we get the tools? We have a pretty big social media presence. my wife and I are both on LinkedIn. We have a company account that's also on LinkedIn. Excuse me. people can go to our website, sign up for our monthly newsletter. We give a lot of free tips. There's a lot of resources and tips on our website. And So that and by now we've you know worked with the SEO and all that that if you're if you Google co-op or condo consultant NYC, we're gonna come up. So we have been doing it enough that we are you know a trusted resource. So they'll say, hey We we have our buildings financials, we don't we don't know what it means. Can you can you help us out? So we do a review. We we literally look at every line item. And when a politician tells you they're looking at every line item in a budget, they're lying. Mostly because they're unqualified, they don't have the skills, you know, they're they they don't come from a finance background. We do that because that's where that's how we make money and that's how we help our clients. If it's four hundred and fifty line items, we look at every single one. We have benchmarks that we we compare. So the first we look for the low-hanging fruit. If we see line items that are way out of whack, you know, we start there. And we have three different services. One is a cost savings service, that's what we're discussing now, where We will take the building's financials, we'll again look through them, and we'll go to a board with about four ideas a month and say, hey, this is what we found. Do you want us to proceed? And number one, they might say, yeah, absolutely. Number two, they might say, hey, we're already working on number three, you know, something else, whatever. And we do that month after month. And the reason we do four at a time is because that's that's typically what a board's bandwidth can handle. These people are volunteers. They have day jobs, they have families, they have social life, whatever. apparently I don't have a social life or whatever, so this is what I do. and it we and we do that until you know we we we can no longer find any savings or you know, sometimes the board will say, Hey, we're kinda busy right now. Well let's pick this up in three months. You know, there's Th there's there's all kinds of reasons. another service we do is project management. So I think you had mentioned, you know, we do particularly complex projects. interesting one we had recently. The board had intended to do a particular project on their own. a month or so in they realized they were just over their head and they they gave us a call. They said, hey, after all, you know, we do want to hire. They were electrifying the building. So they were putting in a domestic hot water heater, heat pumps, getting rid of their boiler completely, getting getting off of oil completely, getting rid of their boiler. So it was complex because we had to deal with the architect we had to coordinate with the architect, the engineer, the construction crew, the board, and the super. Con Ed, we had to pull in more electricity from the street. That involves permitting and coordinating with Con Ed. the Department of Buildings, Expeditors, you name it. So there's all these moving parts and it's kinda like a zipper. If one tooth gets out of line, the entire thing is stalled. And that costs money and waste everybody's time and and no other vendor can work on their part. until the one previous has been completed. So we were actually able to bring that in time and under their budget, including our fee. So that's what I mean by I look, we do all kinds of projects, but this one was particularly complex and we were able to you know do what we did and the board was very satisfied and they're one of our better recommendations right now. And then finally, when a building is just at their wits' end and they they're ready to divorce their manager, their property manager, the building depends on their property manager for advice and et cetera. The one thing they can't go to their property manager is say, Hey, can you find us another one? So they come to us, we work with them, we have a turnkey service. We have a new manager that's right a right fit for their building in their particular situation, and we do that within 60 days. And to date, we have not had a single client who used us for that service fire their, fire the manager that we helped them find. Steven Weinstock (20:02) How do you benchmark one building against others? benchmarking the operating costs. Mark Foley (20:10) Sure, so through experience, first of all, but there are some costs that you can benchmark based on the number of units. So one unit for insurance it should cost x x amount of dollars per unit. if it's another cost energy usage, square feet. So it it depends on the cost, but you know, we were able to do that over time just looking at you know hunt hundreds of building and just storing data. You know, my my wife in particular, Tina Larsson, is the as she likes to think of herself, the spreadsheet queen. And she's just one of those people that loves She'll she'll she loves reading a prospectus. that's so we we get in the weeds and we have different skills that complement each other and it's through really just experience. Steven Weinstock (21:12) What are some of the craziest, audacious chutzpah expenses that you've seen and encountered that, you know, were just way over the top and, you know, easy to fix? Mark Foley (21:28) So one so as as you probably know, real estate and real estate in New York can be let's say an interesting industry. the insurance side of that is particularly interesting. So we had a building, this was probably 10 years ago. We their insurance was up for renewal, so we said, you know, let us use one of our partners, we'll come back with a proposal. Our proposal could have saved them $125,000. Savings. Now at that time, insurance has gone way up over the years, but at that time we had not seen a policy that was $125,000. This was $125,000 in savings. And I told the board, I said, insurance is an interesting business. This is what the this is what they're going to tell you, and they're going to try to scare you, and et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. no, we understand it. We're businessmen and you know, blah, blah, blah. Bottom line, they came back and they said, no, they they told us this and this and this, exactly like you said, but we decided to stay with them. And I said, you do remember that I told you that the managing agent also is an owner of the insurance company, remember? yeah, yeah, yeah, but you know, we we have to trust them. But you know, we want you to keep working, because as you know, we're we're always looking to save money. And by the way, th this we had just started working with this building. This was the third item that could have saved them. I think I think with the insurance we were close to three hundred thousand dollars. They said no to everything and every single thing we said, yeah, we'll we'll Right, when the phone doesn't ring, that's me. But a hundred and twenty five thousand overcharge on insurance policy, I I think is audacious. And I spoke with a friend of mine who's a lawyer, I said, and I told him the story, he's like, Wow. And I said, is that actionable by the board? He said, that actually is. That's you know, beyond violation of fiduciary duty. So It's amazing the liability that boards will put themselves in. Steven Weinstock (23:40) Do you ever see, besides Audacious, any funny business? Any kickbacks? Any payoffs? Mark Foley (23:48) Yes, yes. Steven Weinstock (23:51) How d how does that happen? What what what have you seen and what's you know, what have heard that's that's happened with other buildings? Mark Foley (23:58) Yeah, so those buildings generally don't work with us because you know you're you're not gonna want an auditor come in when you're cooking the books in your company. there was a person who lived in a building, he was not on the board, but he was trying to introduce me to the board. He said, Our vice president is completely corrupt. He said first of all, he's drunk all the time, and when he does, he tells stories. He said, We just had a leak in the roof. Company that fixed it, he was bragging that he got $30,000 in kickbacks. And he said, imagine the the the guy getting the kickback said, and imagine that's only one project. Imagine how much I get. In my own building, when we fired, well, I was on the board, we've fired the super. We notice our dry cleaning bills were cut in half. all kinds of stuff like that that he was obviously using his own stuff. Yeah, you know, we know we had his hand out because the vendors would all tell us. you know that's that's not uncommon. we were working with one building and and they wanted us to change their manager. We actually ended up saving the relationship. So we sometimes work as marriage counselors too. But they wanted us to look at redesigning their Laundry room. So brought in one of our partners, walked around, and I said to the superintendent, the super was overseeing, I said to the the superintendent, what are you looking to get out of this? And he says, Well, they usually fill up my my laundry card every month. I said, No, no, that's that's not what I meant. What are you looking for the room? But he he was, you know, very upfront about it. Steven Weinstock (25:37) Yeah, honesty is the best policy. What kind of mistakes do you see the boards or the owners making money, make with money? Mark Foley (25:47) not not treating it as their own. not treating it like a business. and we tell boards all the time, you know, and I've said it before, I'll probably say it five more times before we're finished, your building is a business, it needs to be run like one. The board can't just say, hey, we hired a property manager, we trust them, that's their job. It's it's your building. You are the board of directors. Think about your favorite neighborhood restaurant. You go there three, four times a month. Every single time you go there, you see the owner. The owner doesn't just say, Well, I hired a manager, I'll meet with him for one hour once a month. He'd be out of business. And we try to impress that upon the board too. So sometimes it's just not realizing the responsibility they have. another thing is them just, you know, wanting to be friends with everybody and say, we'll do this. We say, look, you've got bylaws, you've got house rules. That's your constitution. You have to follow the constitution. You have to treat everybody the same, whether you like them or not, whether they think it's right or wrong, and you have to be consistent. Being consistent and treating everybody the same cures a lot of problems. And the other thing is communication. Steven Weinstock (27:07) What kind of money just overall money are we talking about? give me an example of some of the biggest, most expensive buildings in New York City, probably Manhattan. What kind of budgets are we talking about? I assume every month each co-op owner is paying a fee. Most of that fee probably goes to Sometimes heat, sometimes a doorman salary, you know, other amenities in the building. How high could some of these monthly fees run? And you multiply that by the units of the building. I mean, what are some of the big biggest numbers you've seen or heard of or just know about in New York? What kind what kind of money are we talking about? Mark Foley (27:52) Sure. So in a co-op, the real estate taxes are included in the monthly charge. In a condo, you get two separate bills. You get your monthly fee and your common charges and you get a separate real estate bill. Co-op it's combined. In a co-op, roughly fifty percent of that is real estate taxes. And you again condo you're getting two bills, it's probably the same, they're probably almost equal. So w what those charges are for my building, my building is 165 units, we have about a four million dollar budget. So I have a an apartment's about a thousand square feet. My monthly charges are trying think is it can we have a we pay separately for the gym and all that, it's all combined. R roughly twenty five hundred dollars a month. And that's about average for a you know a mid tier building. Now if you're looking at Park Avenue, you can be b paying fifteen thousand, you can be paying fifty thousand a month. yeah. Steven Weinstock (29:03) Fifty thousand a month. Wow. Mark Foley (29:06) My goal is to pay fifty thousand a month. Steven Weinstock (29:08) Yeah, me too. Me too. Me too. I'm assuming most of your clients are based in New York? Mark Foley (29:15) Yes, we have worked in Chicago. next year we're planning on reaching out branching out into Florida. But yes, you know, our word of mouth referrals, everything, you know, there are you know, tens of thousands of buildings in New York, so it's target rich environment. Steven Weinstock (29:35) If I'm a developer today, would I what would be a reason I would make it a co op building and not a condo building today? Mark Foley (29:44) very good question. I think if you were going for I wanna say you're you're going for that exclusivity where you can choose your own neighbors and all that, but so many of the new b condo buildings are very high end. they're going for, you know, six and even ten thousand dollars a square foot. So it's already fairly selective in a sense, and people today prefer The freedom you get with a condo. Again, you own it, you can buy it, you don't even have to move in, you can rent it out. So I I don't see co-ops making a comeback as far as new construction. You know, never say never, that can always change as you know whims change. But I I I I would not advise a developer right now and happy to have somebody tell me I'm wrong. Steven Weinstock (30:36) Do you ever have bad tenants or well, let me ask you this before. In a co op, am I able to rent out my apartment or it depends on the rules of that co op board? Mark Foley (30:50) Depends on the rules. Generally there's a limit, so some buildings have you can rent them out for a maximum of two years every ten years. And that's that's fairly common. Others have changed their rules and bylaws that, you know, they're they're much more liberal. But you know, the idea is you want the thinking is that you want people who live there who, you know, have ownership who were you know, no nobody washes a a rental car. You know, so you don't want people in a rental car in your building. Steven Weinstock (31:21) Got it understood and great analogy actually. nobody washes the rental car. That is true. I just returned a rental car two days ago. Mark Foley (31:28) Mm-hmm. Steven Weinstock (31:29) And I did not wash it. I didn't fill it up with gas and I said, you know, I gotta make my flight and if you have to charge me for the two or three gallons that were missing, go for it. What do you guys do? What does a co-op board do when there's a tenant that is rowdy or not paying and therefore rowdy, ever have the issue with squatters? New York City is known as a very tough city to be a landlord in terms of landlord tenant rules and payments. Do do you ever have any spillover where a condo a co op board has to get involved? Mark Foley (32:06) yes. not uncommon at all. Squatting is a little less common because you have a doorman, you know who lives there, who doesn't live there. Most buildings will have a guest policy that the guests cannot stay more than thirty days because after that it becomes much more difficult to evict them. Steven Weinstock (32:31) Air Airbnb's Airbnb issues with co-ops? Mark Foley (32:35) People try that, they generally get found out. somebody has a cousin coming to stay with them. z there's your different cousin every month coming to stay with them, So and Steven Weinstock (32:47) Right, right. Mark Foley (32:48) the as as far as you know not paying their their monthlies, that that does happen. The first thing you do is notify the bank and they generally take it from there. You may have to notify the building's lawyer. That's generally charged back to the perpetrator. if they don't have a mortgage, if they've you know paid off their mortgage or they bought in cash, it's a little more difficult. There's no bank to have first dibs at, and then you generally have to go the legal route. It's very difficult. as you know and others watching may not be aware, but New York is very tenant friendly. People have gone years without paying and the judge just puts it off, puts it off, puts it off. Steven Weinstock (33:38) Any other amenities that add to the income of the building? you mentioned in your building the gym is not included, it's extra. I'm assuming Mark Foley (33:48) Correct. Steven Weinstock (33:49) that means it's not mandatory for everybody to pay for it. Mark Foley (33:53) That's right. Steven Weinstock (33:54) if you pay for it you get to use it. I guess it's open to the public maybe to get more income as well, or at s at times, maybe not yours specifically. Mark Foley (34:03) No, not open to the public specifically for insurance and liability. and also the used car analogy as well. you know most buildings don't have a gym that large that they could take in outside people. So typically with a building it's about a twenty percent usage. Steven Weinstock (34:21) Are there are there amenities ever that are open to the public that is part of the income stream for the co op and the co op board? Mark Foley (34:34) If they own the retail space, that would be, but I can't think of anything that's tenant centric, that would be open to the public. Steven Weinstock (34:43) Got it. So if they own the retail space, they rent it out to a dry cleaners, the rent gets paid out to the owners, you know, the condo board or and you know, goes into the income. Mark Foley (34:52) Correct. Steven Weinstock (34:53) but using the cleaners or getting a discount that would just be a regular customer, et cetera. I I I got it. I got it. Mark Foley (34:58) Right. Yeah. Now now some some buildings don't charge for the gym. generally a higher end building and they say, Hey, we want you know, we want don't want to charge people and and that's fine. But in my own building our attitude is, well, why sh there are costs to maintaining the gym. Why should people who aren't using it shoulder those as well instead of just the people that are using it? And now the flip side of that that some people say, well it's an amenity, it adds value to the entire building, they're getting the benefit of the added value. Well yes, but they're not using it. So I I'm of the mind that only the people who use it should have to bear the cost. Steven Weinstock (35:42) When a developer comes develops these buildings, they are in it until the last unit is sold. Is that typically what their involvement is? Mark Foley (35:51) Yes. generally they there is a percentage and I for a n a new development before the plan is effective and I f not I've never developed. I don't know if it's fifty or sixty percent have to be sold and the plan is deemed effective, et cetera. Oftentimes the developer will buy up units and they will keep them themselves, sell them off as time goes by, they maintain a position or positions on the board. And eventually they sell them off and then their hands are clean. Steven Weinstock (36:26) What other ways of income are building owners able to or build or bo condo boards, co-op boards able to get just I I I ask this because I'm a multifamily owner and I get pitched all the time from various different vendors on making more money, you know, how to eke some extra funds out of my tenants, as an amenity. Just to give an example, and it's a it's a company I'm involved in, they do a bulk internet cable TV marketing and they will come to a building, they will ask to put flyers for cable vision or optimum or ATT or whatever it is in the lobby and any tenant that signs up, typically with their cable company, whoever the local cable company is, some of the residuals are given to the to the landlord. I I've done this on quite a few of the buildings we own. it's almost a no brainer. There's no tenant friction, nothing signed up. But there must be besides this, there must be other ways to try to monetize and bring in extra income into the building. Mark Foley (37:38) Sure. So a couple of the standard ones are the laundry room. If people you know, if they if if you don't have in unit washer dryer, you have to go you have to get your laundry done. So you have to do your laundry. another one is storage facilities, in storage units in the basement or wherever. people can either buy them, some buildings sell them outright. if you're Steven Weinstock (38:00) Some buildings sell their parking spot. Parking spots also, right? Mark Foley (38:05) and I was gonna say if you're out in Brooklyn or Queens, you may have parking parking spots, some rent, some sell, up to your you know up to your personal choice. if you're renting, obviously it's a continual stream, you can budget that. If you're selling, generally it's a much higher price, you get the money up front. You know, you you you've got a f you know, unfortunately you can never sell it again or get any other income from that. But it depends what's right for your situation. Some people have a roof deck that obviously it's you don't charge for that, it's open to anyone, but if you want to have a private party, you can rent that out. Steven Weinstock (38:47) If a listener owns a small apartment building, what are some things that they can do this week to find the savings? Mark Foley (38:57) energy efficient appliances, energy efficient bulbs in the lobby, put the lobby lights or or hallway lights on motion sensor. there's no reason to pay for electricity. let's let's say midnight to six AM when nobody's in the in the hallway. The hallways don't go completely dark. There's little night lights or so to speak that stay on, and then you open your door and you can set it to any free not frequency, any sensitivity that you want, that as soon as you open the door, lights go on. you can have it so sensitive that if somebody's behind their door, the light will go on. But I mean your autumn yeah, you put you put that in and your electricity costs have come down immediately. We have a policy that we recommend that for water, that if somebody is doing a bathroom renovation, so you you can't force people to do this, but if it's a renovation they need approval, then you can. So that they must have low-flow appliances, they must have low-flow toilet, 1.2 gallon max, etc. It's a huge savings on water in the building. And over time We found every over the course of a few years, you know, four or five years, you'll get about twenty-five percent of people have done that because that's just the life cycle of people doing renovations, buying into a new build you know, buying a new apartment they have old fixtures or just a you know, old bathroom they just wanna change. So that could be significant as well. Steven Weinstock (40:39) Okay, so you mentioned the low flow showers, that reminds me. there was that famous Seinfeld episode where Jerry and Kramer you know, they were getting upset that they're building for forcing it. They go to the black market and they're buying high flow fixtures. a show that takes place in New York, very New York centric and And when I saw that originally I just laughed along, but now that you're saying it as a potential rule or by a condo by a co-op board, it's it actually reminds me of that. you know, your your wealth of this topic is very interesting. You know, for anybody who just likes history, New York history, New York centric know the comings and goings, co-ops. I'm sure you have a lot of good stories. I think you should write a book. maybe keep out some of the names. Steven Weinstock (41:34) But definitely put together a book and I think it would be a big hit in in New York. Mark it was it was great talking to you. I had a good time. We went a little overboard. We're supposed to do about twenty to thirty minutes, but I thoroughly enjoyed this maybe just because you're a fellow New Yorker and It was very interesting to me. tell everybody how they can reach out to you. I'll put it in the show notes, whether it's social media, website, fax number, anything you want to share with anybody. Mark Foley (42:06) Sure, they can go to our website, which is TheFolsonGroup.com, T-H-E-F-O-L-S-O-N Group.com. you go to our website, we have a ton of free tools, tips, etc., advice. We also have that you can sign up for our monthly newsletter, which is more free tips, advice, etc., etc., etc. it's very useful information for boards, particularly any board member, but particularly new board members. We have an onboarding for new board members that they can sign up for on the website. They can also call us directly at 212-472-0114. You will get an AI operator, and it's very well done. They'll be able to direct you to the right place. Steven Weinstock (42:57) Okay, Mark, thank you very much. It was a pleasure. Mark Foley (43:00) Steven, enjoyed it. Thank you. Steven Weinstock (43:02) It was a pleasure having you on. If you got something out of this episode, subscribe to the Wealth Clock podcast. Like it, share it, share it with an owner or a board member of a building that you live in. Maybe you could save yourself some money or you can upset them. Mark Foley (43:23) And if you share it with a board member, that is our target audience. Steven Weinstock (43:26) Mark, thank you very much. I appreciate it. Until the next one. Mark Foley (43:31) Thank you.

    About Mark Foley

    Mark Foley is co founder and President of The Folson Group, a New York City consultancy that helps co op and condo boards control costs and manage big capital projects. He has been a co op board president in New York City for 15 years and comes from the world of finance and economics, with a background as a business analyst on Wall Street. He and his wife and business partner, Tina Larsson, reviewed their own building's books like investors and, as Mark describes it, cut about $340,000 from the budget. The Folson Group offers cost savings reviews, project management for complex building projects, and a turnkey property manager search.

    Timestamps

    Click any timestamp to jump to that point in the video

    Enjoy this episode?

    Get weekly insights on real estate investing, operations, and wealth building delivered to your inbox.

    Free, no spam. Unsubscribe anytime.